Wednesday, September 1, 2010

"Let them eat static"

Much as I love the final trench run in Star Wars, and the destruction of Caprica from the original Battlestar: Galactica, I present to you the best space battle scene ever filmed. And the reason? Because it concentrates on the characters, not the ships and explosions. The best RPG battles share that same trait. It's not about how many orcs you kill; it's about how the battle impacts the characters.

10 comments:

BlUsKrEEm said...

I had a sudden vision of an indie space opera where combat is resolved by out acting your opponent.

Matt said...

Well said!

The Badger King said...

"To the last, I will grapple with thee... from Hell's heart, I stab at thee! For hate's sake, I spit my last breath at thee!"

Classic.

JasperAK said...

Wrath of Khan is an excellent example of your point. If only assholes like michael bay would learn what elements create the most powerful scenes.

Rob Conley said...

My personal favorite is Severed Dreams Episode from Babylon 5 where B5 breaks away from the earth alliance.

James said...

All of which brings to mind my favorite Star Trek episode: Balance of Terror.

Mark said...

Yep, the Khan battle is a good one, and I especially enjoyed his choice of final words, but I think my favorite ( extended ) battle is the one between Kirk and the Romulan commander on Balance of Terror - always reminded me of two WW2 submarine commanders trying to outfox each other.

Mark said...

@ James ( in Reverend Mother Mohiam voice ) " Get out of my mind!"

LOL

mortellan said...

Augh! What a cruel reminder. I had a chance to see this movie on the big screen at Gencon last month and was talked out of it by my friends. I am still kicking myself.

baronkohinar said...

Joseph,

I agree with you 100%; the best space fight of them all. Plus, I'm a film student here, so that makes me an expert right? ;-)

Here's hoping if they *really* feel they must do Khan in the next Abrahms movie, they don't screw it up - or it's going to alienate a bunch of their fans (no pun intended). It's quite dangerous; it could either be very successful for them or blow up in their faces but such is the nature of these things.